SpottedleafxFirestar vs. Sandstormxfirestar?

[Reverie]

yo. dis is a thread that is about Firestar, Sandstorm and Spottedleaf

cast opinions below~

[Bellatrix]

SandXFire....SpottedXFire felt way to rushed and awkward and plus Sandstorm was more likable to me than Spottedleaf no offense but it really made me mad when Sandstorm named Leafpool after Spottedleaf....like ugh your mate isn't over his dumb little highschool crush and your okay with it? and you name your kit after her? Yes I know she was ticked at first but still if my future bf or whatever still likes one of his childhood crushes and still dreams about her (I've been through this before btw thats why I don't want a bf for a WHILE)....um I'm gone bye and I would never give him another chance....ugh like Sandy should not have to put up with Firestar's bullcrap

[NightWarrior4Life]

I mean, I'm totally against SpottedXFire cause don't get me wrong, the whole idea of a childhood crush is cute and whenever someone is in a troubling situation like Firepaw was, I always like it when they have someone to stick up for them. But after Spottedleaf died, she basically just stalked Fireheart in his dreams and the fact that she's like "soon my love" and "I died because I love you" and then all he says is "noooooo! Come back!" Pathetic!

[dino.]

I really don't like SpottedxFire. It was cute, but maybe a little too soon. And the fact that she was killed twice kind of makes it pointless. It was sad when she was killed by Mapleshade, yes, but Firestar was just like "No, don't leave me!" You have a mate, get over it! Clan life isn't all mice and moonlight. There's gonna be some losses. But Spottedleaf did save Sandstorm, so I think that she knew Spottedleaf and Firestar could never be happy together. There's my opinion.

[goddess of ducks]

I'm for SandXFire whole heartedly. I loved the idea of Spotted being there almost like a best friend for him, but when they started calling each other lovey Dover names after she died it was weird. It would have been so much better had the Erin's either 1.) kept her as a good friend that just liked to protect him from Starclan or 2.) have her become more like an older sister figure to Fire. Thatrightbthere would have made much more sense, especially if the still wanted to keep her coming back to help from Starclan.

[Slash-GNR]

I really don't like sandstorm in the first place. She seems to needy and is a real jerk to firepaw u til he starts to become this great hero. It just really makes me mad, and I think spotted would have loved firepaw no matter what. She liked him before he was a great hero. Plus sandstorm just seems touching a diva to me...

[Tundra]

Makes sence (don't judge my spelling! -3-) Although, Spottedleaf saved sandstorm because she knew that Sandstorm made Firestar happy. But, as I just typed that I realized that Firestar must not care about Spottedleaf because if Sandstorm makes him happy then he must have never cared about Spottedleaf... Hmmm... -3-

[Trashy Sky]

spottedxfire was nice as like a cute little 'oh firepaw has a little crush on spottedleaf how cute' but it was kinda weird as fire kept loving spotted like what but sandxfire felt rushed and they didn't feel compatible together honestly

[wren]

The whole thing was awful sad. For both sides. You must understand that spottedleaf was a good cat nontheless. She would have been better off as a good friend or best friend for fire and grey. I really liked her though. Sandpaw hated firepaw at first but it also lead up to a great love story. Though it started out with hatred in the end it's all so cute. I wouldn't have wanted firestar to end up loving spottedleaf though. If he didn't carry on with the anger he felt and trying to avenge her death where would we be now? Fireheart wouldn't have been one of the best made characters of the series. Anyway this was about the relationship not whatever that was but I agree, spotted and fire were certainly not meant to be. Though I would have enjoyed to see her live on. Unfortunately things aren't that way.

[Moonsong12]

Sandstorm and Firestar. I like both, but Spottedleaf and Firestar would never have worked out. Plus it's fun to see two cats with occasional fiery tempers have kits, whom are both stubborn in my opinion.