Tigerstar and swift paws death is messed up..

**Maccabeus** · #1 March 11th, 2023, 11:55 AM

How tigerstar died still is messed up to me and swift paw to

**MockingRabbit** · #2 March 13th, 2023, 05:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maccabeus

How tigerstar died still is messed up to me and swift paw to

Can't really remember Swiftpaw's, so I searched it up. Though I do however agree that Tigerstar's death was. All nine lives to one wound?

**sock** · #3 March 13th, 2023, 01:49 PM

i thought it was a little funny how Tigerstar was defeated by a tiny trash gremlin. But i do agree that it sucked... i was hoping for a more gruesome, drawn-out death that would fulfill my dark need for nightmare-inducing book scenes

**poppy** · #4 March 18th, 2023, 01:33 AM

why did I read the title as taylor swift's mess

**Levi 99** · #5 March 18th, 2023, 02:33 AM

I was actually a little satisfied when I first read that part, thinking he got what he deserved. But then later on I realized that I really wanted Fireheart to kill him instead.

**VERVAINSNOW** · #6 April 20th, 2023, 06:08 PM

It's been ages since I've read the first arc, but compared to Tigerstar's death I've read much worse.

**Bean** · #7 April 20th, 2023, 06:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ~*The_Collector*~

i thought it was a little funny how Tigerstar was defeated by a tiny trash gremlin. But i do agree that it sucked... i was hoping for a more gruesome, drawn-out death that would fulfill my dark need for nightmare-inducing book scenes

yesh, how did A LEADER WITH NINE LIVES HAVE ALL OF THEM STRIPPED AWAY BY A tiny gremlin?! Like, how does that make sense?

**Toya Todoroki** · #8 April 20th, 2023, 06:28 PM

There are wounds out there that can't be healed by the nine lives, because of how server they are... tiny might have been a runt but he's been training ruthlessly and probably has been killing cats for most of his lifeafter he became Scourge. he injured Tigerstar so badly that he couldn't live so each life was stripped from him rapidly,for the wound was so server that it was fatal, and nine lives or not, he'd have died either way, it wouldn't be realistic for him to survive that fatal a wound...

as for Swiftpaws death, that was his own stupidity... i'll be blunt bout that, so he wanted to impress his mentally disturbed leader, i get that, but Fighting DOGS? dogs that are twice or 3 times larger then him! a full pack of them too... i'm sorry but i judge him as stupid idiot

**lem~** · #9 April 22nd, 2023, 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ~*The_Collector*~

i thought it was a little funny how Tigerstar was defeated by a tiny trash gremlin. But i do agree that it sucked... i was hoping for a more gruesome, drawn-out death that would fulfill my dark need for nightmare-inducing book scenes

FRED!? WTH!?
I agree with @Levi 99 as well! It was satsifying but it would've been better is FireStar killed him...

**BEAR.** · #10 April 24th, 2023, 08:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DynaMight

as for Swiftpaws death, that was his own stupidity... i'll be blunt bout that, so he wanted to impress his mentally disturbed leader, i get that, but Fighting DOGS? dogs that are twice or 3 times larger then him! a full pack of them too... i'm sorry but i judge him as stupid idiot

did they know the full extent of the dogs when swift/bright went out??

i haven't read the books in at least a decade, so my memory is pretty fuzzy. i recall there weren't a lot of details of what was going on at snakerocks, so swift wanted to check it out and handle whatever was going on - they weren't aware of how dangerous the area had become