What do You think is the saddest warriors book?

[Weekend-Wondering]

What do you think is the saddest warrior cats book?


I personally think it’s Crookedstar’s promise, but many people have other opinions.

[WhitesilverQueen]

I need to read Crookedstar's promise, but currrently I think Yellowfang's secret is the saddest.
@Wintermist

[Raven~]

I think it’s Mapleshade’s Vengeance. That whole book was sadness.
@Wintermist

[sunnyheart]

i totally think blue star's death was the saddest i was almost crying when i read that part

[Bean]

The sun trail. I was sooooo sad when storm died

[Weekend-Wondering]

BUmp

[TheNyanCatMinecart]

Squirrelflight's Hope because I was so mad at StarClan and Bramblestar, and Leafpool's death was depressing, especially with that epilogue where Squirrelpaw and Leafpaw were promising that they'd never lose each other.

The First Battle I think it was called, with the Gray Wing, Clear Sky, and Thunder drama.

I really liked the end of A Light in the Mist because it was sad. I won't spoil it since that book has only been out for a few months, though.

[Courage]

definently The last hope because of Frestars death, anddd that one book where Needletail died and The book where GrayWing died @Wintermist

[QueenOtter]

The Last Hope...
Every time I red the end bit about the Great Battle I feel like crying! Spottedleaf's death was soooo sad, same with Firestar's, Ferncloud's, Hollyleaf's and Mousefur's deaths... And also all the ThunderClan deaths in the battle were... devasting...

[IcarusUntamed]

Spotted’leafs Heart.
I’ve never read it but I’ve seen enough reviews of it to know it is the darkest thing Warriors has ever written and it’s just plain sad