How has no one brought up the best character

[sol.]

 

I'm gonna have to agree with Fred on this one. The way Scourge fought and killed Tigerstar was too rushed, considering how he was a leader with nine lives. Scourge would've need a lot of strength to rip open a cat's stomach, much less mangle the body enough to have all nine lives taken away. And when you take into account the fact that he is literally tiny, it doesn't make much sense biologically or just in general. It was like Tigerstar was treated more as a plot device than an actual character.

Plus, Scourge doesn't use any of his 'strength' on Firestar? He just kills him once and calls it a day, at least until Firestar comes back to take Scourge's life from him. On top of that, he used dog claws, instead of his own power.

[ @Rosepaaw ]

[Raccoontail]

Dude yeah I agree. Especially when he looks at Firestar and is like "Oh diddly darn goodness, I killed you though!!!!" and Firestar just k*lls him with barely any effort. He didn't care when his "deputy" died, he just liked how powerful he was. He had no personality, even in the Rise of Scourge. He is indeed a tiny trash gremlin.

[Ymir]

He wasnt strong but he was smart

Instead of power he used what made him famous into a weapon that he can do so much for him

And showing weakness is the worst thing you can do in a clan of killers showing no remorse for bone (no matter how tragic it is) was a simple leader choice

And Eren had to nerf him some way that way was just having him not know about lives, starclan, etc

He is a beautiful written character despite not showing it