I HATE THE KIN PROPHECY THING-

[fishy]

OK WHY IS EVERY SINGLE PROTAGONIST A FIRESTAR OR TIGERSTAR (the first) KIN LIKE- LETS INCLUDE SOME BACKROUND CHARACTERS OR SOMETHING.

FIRESTAR IS A LEGITIMATE JAKE FROM ROBLOX ROYALE HIGH AT THIS POINT BRO WITH HIS KIN BEING LIKE THE LITTLE "GIRLFRIENDS" THAT THEY GET IN EVERY SINGLE SERVER LIKE WHAT

[JackHunt_17]

yeah like even up to Starless Clan, Nightheart is Firestars kin. At least he hates it though.

[odessa]

not only that, but like-
Firestar's family is lowkey a bit boring? I want to see how cats outside of thunderclan/his family are just existing. I don't even ask for much, let's just have some WindClan or RiverClan prophecy/arc plot for once. I'm a bit sick of ShadowClan vs ThunderClan (aka Firestar's whole family) Sometimes I just wanna know how Thrushpelt is doing, or maybe meet somebody new? In the novellas and super editions, you can kind of see that, but I really wanted some whole set of 6 books about a new character. I guess that's why I liked Dawn of the Clans a lot, even though it lacked the nostalgic clans since it (no spoiler) started at the very beginning. ):

[gravekeeper.]

We need Dawn of the Clans manga

[Beaan]

We need Dawn of the Clans manga
there is a book series known as Dawn of the Clans

[shaae_26]

there is a book series known as Dawn of the Clans
manga is comics.

[SqurrelTail]

not only that, but like-
Firestar's family is lowkey a bit boring? I want to see how cats outside of thunderclan/his family are just existing. I don't even ask for much, let's just have some WindClan or RiverClan prophecy/arc plot for once. I'm a bit sick of ShadowClan vs ThunderClan (aka Firestar's whole family) Sometimes I just wanna know how Thrushpelt is doing, or maybe meet somebody new? In the novellas and super editions, you can kind of see that, but I really wanted some whole set of 6 books about a new character. I guess that's why I liked Dawn of the Clans a lot, even though it lacked the nostalgic clans since it (no spoiler) started at the very beginning. ):
I feel the same way, but what disturbs me most is the fact that the prophecy is: "There will be three, Kin of your Kin" and that obviously means grandchildren, and yet we have Dovewing. Cloudtail is firestar's Kin (Kin number = 1) and his daughter is Whitewing (Kin number = 2) and then Whitewing's daughter is Dovewing, (Kin number = 3) so Dovewing would be "Kin of your Kin of your Kin" also the books compleatly ignore the fact that Dovewing isn't a direct decendent of Firestar, and don't even get me started on the fourth cat thing.

[fishy]

FOR REAL ITS SO ANNOYING

[gravekeeper.]

Hollyleaf should’ve been the third or at least fourth cat

[Silvershadow13]

Hollyleaf should’ve been the third or at least fourth cat

YES! She deserved it after everything she went through.

[gravekeeper.]

YES! She deserved it after everything she went through.
Or Ivypool.

[Silvershadow13]

Or Ivypool.

Ah, yes, she deserves some praise too!
I honestly think that one of the more main dark forest cats should have double crossed the DF, just because the battle was almost boring at times and it would have made a great addition to any prophecy.

[gravekeeper.]

Ah, yes, she deserves some praise too!
I honestly think that one of the more main dark forest cats should have double crossed the DF, just because the battle was almost boring at times and it would have made a great addition to any prophecy.
Maybe Sparrowfeather or Snowtuft?

[Silvershadow13]

Maybe Sparrowfeather or Snowtuft?



Both of them actually help the living clan cats at the end of the newer series 'The Broken Code, to defeat the imposter, and Snow gift actually dies for a second time, saving, I think it was Rootspring by taking on Ashfur

[gravekeeper.]

Both of them actually help the living clan cats at the end of the newer series 'The Broken Code, to defeat the imposter, and Snow gift actually dies for a second time, saving, I think it was Rootspring by taking on Ashfur


Yes it was Rootspring. And I picked those 2 because they were alive during OOTS and cause they helped the broken code protags.

[Silvershadow13]

Yes it was Rootspring. And I picked those 2 because they were alive during OOTS and cause they helped the broken code protags.

They are actually two of my fav. Dark Forest cats mostly because how underrated they are, but I think, both would have made a good contribution to the Kin of Kin prophecy, like maybe something like one who you think is a foe may actually be your greatest allies, type of thing.

[Kacey!]

OK WHY IS EVERY SINGLE PROTAGONIST A FIRESTAR OR TIGERSTAR (the first) KIN LIKE- LETS INCLUDE SOME BACKROUND CHARACTERS OR SOMETHING.

FIRESTAR IS A LEGITIMATE JAKE FROM ROBLOX ROYALE HIGH AT THIS POINT BRO WITH HIS KIN BEING LIKE THE LITTLE "GIRLFRIENDS" THAT THEY GET IN EVERY SINGLE SERVER LIKE WHAT


OHMYGOD EXACTLY- FIRST OFF MOST THINGS TAKE PLACE IN THUNDERCLAN... I WOULD ENJOY A SERIES NOT BASED AROUND THEM FOR ONCE PLEASE. AND AT THIS POINT EVERYONE IN THUNDERCLAN IS RELATED TO FIRE OR TIGER