Fireheart V.S Brambleclaw

[Weekend-Wondering]

If Fireheart and Brambleclaw went to fight against each other, who would win? Both characters made their way into becoming leaders, and both saved ThunderClan from terrible dangers. Though what were to happen if the two toms met in battle? Of course, I’m sure they would refuse to fight each other in the real books, if THAT didn’t matter, who do you think would win? And why?

Choose wisely

[Courage]

thats a hard one maibe Firestar sinse he killed scourge? Wintermist

[Weekend-Wondering]

bUmp!

[flopsy]

I'm going to have to go with my buddy Fireheart

[Red'fur]

Fireheart gotta love that Orange pelt man not to mention he's way stronger and wiser than Brambleclaw.

[PlayWithFire]

Fireheart, cause he killed Scourge and he is much, much wiser and stronger that Brambleclaw.

[poppy]

Fireheart bc he has my blessing
who else absolutely detests brambleclaw?

[bubble[error].]

Well, Fireheart was Brambleclaw's mentor, so they may know the same skills. But I'd say Fireheart

[IcarusUntamed]

I personally headcannon Bramble’claw would be bigger and bulkier than Fire’heart who I see naturally quite thin, so Bramble would have the upper paw there.
Bramble is also like, not a very good person so he’d probably have a little less remorse for fire’heart who may be more hesitant.
I personally also don’t see Fire’heart as that great a fighter. Sure he beat scourge but scourge has the body of a week older kitten and Fire’heart also lost to him at first before he enabled cheats and respawned at full health.

I believe Bramble’claw would win and be unapologetic in doing so

[Beaan]

Fireboi all the way. He saved that dumb bramble and bc he older, but i still like bramble

[ThePiffle]

Brambleclaw, it's logical since he's larger, though I may be wrong. Though that doesn't mean Brambleclaw is a better character, Bramble is just a copy paste of Fireheart.

[duskfire1]

I despise Brambleclaw, so FIRE ALL DA WAY.
Tho, if Brambleclaw is bigger like everyone else is saying, he is Tigerstar's offspring, and he and Fireheart have fought many battles, and Fireheart has never lost. Even though Scourge killed Tigerstar, he was much smaller and only used his claws, and Fireheart beat Scourge, which meant if it was a Fire-Tiger battle, Firestar would probably win, and since Brambleclaw is nicer than Tigerstar, but meaner that Firestar, I'd say he'd beat Brambleclaw.
IF, Brambleclaw was bigger, and Fireheart was more lean, the battle would be more evened out, because Fireheart would have the speed and defense advantage, while Brambleclaw would have the offense an probably defense advantage. Speed would help Fire for his defense, and Brambleclaw's supposed bulkiness would help with his offense and defense.

Honestly? I think Fireheart would Win.

[azu-azulu]

fireheart

[IcarusUntamed]

Bramble’claw has the brute force advantage but Fire’heart is known for being a bit more lean and muscular.

Now are we talking about the Bramble’claw we are shown or the Bramble’claw the Erin’s wants us to think is being shown

Because the Bramble’claw the Erin’s want us to think is being shown would probably end up loosing cuz he’s such a ‘nice guy’ and would refuse to fight his GFs dad

But the Bramble’claw that’s actually written would not hesitate to bodyslam the former protagonist

But we’re leaving our Plot Armor, Fire’heart has so much plot armor that Bramble’claw (who only has half the plot armor Fire’heart does) would not stand a chance under Prophecy Mans witty remarks and GoodGuy™️ Powers

[elswhere]

i side with GoldenDays

also stop bringing up scrouge he's just some edgy emo week old kit who though spiked collars were cool an animal jam.