What's your favorite super edition?

[Adderbite]

I think that mine is Mothflight's Vision.

I really related to Mothflight on a personal level. I desperately wanting to prove myself worthy to my mom as a child, which I saw happening between her and Windstar. I also have ADHD and Mothflight perfectly represents someone with it, imo. It also had a nice message - people that have mental disabilities aren't necessarily sick, they just have a different brain wiring. I think that's why StarClan gave her the duty of becoming the first medicine cat. They felt that her brain wiring was designed for it. I also really appreciated how the Clan cats started to recognize that her herb gathering was important.

I also really like Crowfeather's Trial. It was satisfying reading him finally getting redemption. But I had a huge issue with Onestar, which kept me from thoroughly enjoying reading about Crowfeather, Breezepelt, Heathertail and Nightcloud. What really holds it back for me is when Onestar says that he's okay with, no SUPPORTS, the stoats destroying ThunderClan. I know he dislikes ThunderClan, but really? That was thoroughly hypocritical. So it's not okay for WindClan to be driven out by ShadowClan, and left to starve, but it is okay for WindClan to board up a cave entrance to drive stoats into ThunderClan territory? Viciously mauling queens, kits and elders? Ripping all the cats to shreds? If that's not evil motivation, then I don't know what is. Onewhisker... what in the heck happened to you?

[|:| Tundra |:|]

Mothflight's Vision is my favorite, too! Tall Shadow is my favorite Warriors character overall, but Moth Flight is the one that I relate to the most. I also just really like DotC books in general; I think they have much better characters and plotlines than most of the others.
Adderbite

[Adderbite]

Mothflight's Vision is my favorite, too! Tall Shadow is my favorite Warriors character overall, but Moth Flight is the one that I relate to the most. I also just really like DotC books in general; I think they have much better characters and plotlines than most of the others.
Adderbite

That is so true, though! Not only that, but it is fascinating reading how the Clans came to be. As for my favorite Warriors cat overall, I think it might be Gray Wing. I really appreciate having the series follow a cat that doesn't become a high rank (or at least not permanently). For some reason, they feel more relate-able and realistic when written that way. Though it probably does help that we follow him until his death. I dislike having to classify any of them as my favorite though, because I have found something enjoyable in just about every cat in the series.

[Aquilex]

My favorite Super Edition was Yellowfang's Secret.Yellowfang's attitude and forbidden love was very tragic. And I've never hated so much as I hated Raggedstar, the selfish furball.

[Broke]

Mine is also Yellowfang's Secret, all the way. I loved the story so much, I can still picture the cover and feel the weight of the book in my hands. The art was wonderful, and Yellowfang seemed to be such a unique and unfortunate character. I couldn't get enough of her

[Wish]

In my opinion, Tallstar's Revenge was the most well-written. I don't care for his character, but the way it was presented was awesome. Yellowfang's Secret is good, but has a couple plot holes. My all time favorite was Mothflight Vision, though. Just... so good and relatable and emotional.

[frog]

Tallstar's Revenge, though Yellowfang's Secret and Bluestar's Prophecy are a close second.

[aleka!]

my favorites are probably moth flight's vision and crookedstar's promise

[Aquilex]

My least favorite is Mothflight's vision just because it's hard for me to read books where the warrior/medicine cat code isn't in place yet {idk why it just is} but my favorite is definitely Crookedstar's Promise

[Wish]

That does make sense about Mothflight's Vision, because it is difficult to get your bearings for the time period and decipher what the code included, if there was a code at all! I personally enjoyed reading about the development of the codes and clans, but I can understand how it would be annoying or confusing to others. :)

[Zath]

I've read only a handful, but I really enjoyed Bramblestar's Storm. Not for him, as I don't really care for Bramblestar, but for all of the other characters. Lionblaze's struggle with himself, Daisy stepping up and showing how far she's come from the frightened queen she had been, even BERRYNOSE was enjoyable in that book, because they all got their own chance to shine. It was also enjoyable to see Bramblestar unsure of himself, and of course we had Graystripe offering grandpa-worthy advice.

My other favorite one has to be Firestar's Quest. My copy was messed up, but I was still able to follow the story. I quickly fell in love with the Skyclan cats, and I was chuckling at Fire's short temper and general freaking out. He had no idea what he was diving into, and his interactions with everyone were enjoyable. His relationship with Sandstorm flourished, and it was amazing to see how she shot up and took on the roles that needed to be taken on. It was great to see young, quirky Firestar, as I had finished Omen of the Stars and was tired of the older, tired Firestar.

I also LOVED Moth Flight's Vision. She's an amazing cat, and I honestly love her with all my heart. I can relate with the trying to live up to my mother's expectations, and her frustration with herself was raw and felt very real to read. Her relationship with Micah was sweet and loving, and I cried when he died along with her. She learned, and grew, and it was an amazing book to read. It's one of the best written super editions.