[BEAR.]

Originally Posted by Timbergrowl

What do you think would have happened if Tigerstar succeeded in making TigerClan?

Who would have died and who would still be alive if this had happened?

Please give me your complete honest answer about what you think would have happened.
@Sasukewolf (madness) @Swiftheart

Pretty much none of the ThunderClan cats in the last few arcs would be alive (given half of them are descended from Firestar, who would've likely been offed by Tigerstar). I don't think TigerClan would've caused as much damage to the forest as others may believe. A huge amount of what Tigerstar was doing was in the hopes of bringing the Clans together as one unit under him. All the violence and bloodshed was means to an end.

Unfortunately, the issue with bringing the Clans together is that so many of the cats were raised to be enemies. There'd be too many tensions within the faction for it to take off, and it's likely the combined Clan would break apart from the inside. It's possible they could've formed the other Clans again, with new leaders to oppose him. Cue the introduction of BloodClan and Tigerstar's brutal demise at the paws of a shrimp.