[Role]

Perhaps she should have gone to a limbo. Kind of like how needletail is now. Needletail has stars in her pelt, but she isn't in StarClan. What if Mapleshade could have been like that?
Mapleshade was kicked out of her Clan and shunned.
Then as she tried to cross the river, her kits were swept away, and her own Clanmate stood by and watched.
Then she was rejected by her mate and his Clan.
Forced to life as a rogue, Mapleshade seeks revenge
She kills two of her Clanmates, one who shunned her, the other who watched. Next, she heads to RiverClan to kill her former mate, and kill his mate. She instead kills her former mate, gets mortally wounded by his apprentice, and crawls away to die.

Could this have been justice? Or was it cruel?
I feel like it was a mix of both.

(Psst! two good mapleshade things are
Marshal Dear MAP
And... Bust Your Kneecaps PMV)