[BEAR.]

Originally Posted by Bloody Bandit

Pretty sure they're just gone, since they're not in a clan and only clan cats are judged to go to either. At least in the books, but WCO is on a separate universe so don't take my word for it.

In the books, if you believed in / know of StarClan/the Dark Forest, you'd go to one or the other depending on your actions and intentions.

If an outsider believed in / knew of them, they'd go to one. Otherwise, they don't. The books and WCO don't currently have a designated afterlife for outsiders who don't know / believe to go to, and the staff isn't planning on adding one since dead cats aren't roleplayed frequently.