[FadingEchoes]

Originally Posted by Trickster~

Well, she did kill a cat (Apple-something), and kinda-sorta ruin Crookedstar's life, but her Clan banished her AND her kits! (Wth?) Her kits died, her mate abandoned her, so I say..both.

Interesting insight, I basically think the same thing.
SPOILERS FOR MAPLESHADE'S VENGEANCE, BLUESTAR'S PROPHECY AND CROOKEDSTAR'S PROMISE
While she did put her kits in danger, it wasn't her fault.(I would blame Bluestar for Mosskit rather than Mapleshade for her kits.) Her clan made her AND her kits leave, while it wasn't the kits' fault. And then Appledusk was a jerk and totally abandoned her at Riverclan.
She did kill Appledusk, Ravenwing, and Frecklewish while she was alive. And basically all of Crookedstar's friends and family.