Dewkit
StarClan | She/Her

A small kit appeared from the starry beyond as they approached the one seeking a second chance. This one was a young warrior who didn't seem to last long in a fight. She took a seat and listened as they spewed their story and their reason for them to hear. So far the kit found no good reason to give them a second try, nothing they said gave them reasons too. "So you spent most of your time fighting some random shadowclan cat that you've ignored that of which went on around you?" she voiced out staring dead in the eye of Adderhaze. None of this screamed 'give me a second chance' to her, just excuse after excuse. "Why should we give it to you when you might just go back to said cat for maybe revenge?" What a waste of their life to seek the thrill of battles when life was more than that.

@Ambereyes

》| Dustpoppy | Dark Forest | She/Her |《

Blue eyes watched from the shadows for a moment, before slipping out, taking note of the young cat who fell quickly in battle. "So? Cats die young all the time, a lot of them come with the same, unimaginative reasoning as you." Her voice was sharp, irritable that her blissful silence was broken for this. Ignoring his remarks about not having love, Dustpoppy scoffed. "If that's your only reasoning to return to the living world, then leave. Not one member of this council would grant your wish to return, not with `but I want to go back`." This cat died because of his own incompetence, unable to back off when the odds weren't in his favor, didn't he see that?

- @Ambereyes @Leafy

Barkblaze | Male + He/Him | StarClan

Barkblaze cast his gaze towards the "warrior" that was asking for another chance at life. He found himself more than displeased and dissatisfied with the given reasons why they deserved life again.
He nearly scoffed when this youngling nearly demanded he be brought back, and whined about how he needed a second chance.
He would have considered Adderhaze in a more.... Positive light, had he not made it blatantly clear that he'd squandered the life he'd been given. To describe the most simple of joys that even an apprentice could experience with ease, and claim that having missed out was reason enough to go back.
Bah.
All it showed was that he never seized his own opportunities to make the most of his life. It would be a waste to send such a meek individual back out into the world.
He promised to make the most of his second chance now, but would he really do anything of substance should he be allowed back? And to think, he'd initially believed he may have had potential when all he'd know was that Adderhaze had died in battle.
He cleared his throat to speak up.

"You may have died a warriors death in the heat of battle, but that is where any interest in allowing you to return ends, and that isn't enough. You do your case no favours by admitting that you took no chances in life to seize opportunities to truly live. Say we let you go back, how do we know you won't simply live another, equally as passive existence as your first one?"
He lowered his head and gazed right into Adderhaze's eyes.
"Your time in the afterlife need not be so bland and unfulfilling. You claim you've never known the rush of victory, but you needn't be alive to experience it. You can find meaning in death."
Barkblaze leaned forward, tilting his head.
"Or do you intend to squander your time in StarClan as you did in life? Will you simply hide away and mope of we deny you this? Are you just another sad, pitiful soul who does nothing to improve their situation while still demanding chances not afforded to everyone?
Or will you prove me wrong?"


[ @Ambereyes ; @Leafy ; @peach ]

Dewkit
StarClan | She/Her