Favorite/Worst Leader

[Tundra]

Name your Favorite and Least Favorite Leader, also give a reason if you'd like

[Zan Partizanne]

BlueStar is my favorite because who doesn't love BlueStar and Onestar is my least favorite because he nearly destroyed his own clan and broke his promise with TallStar to stay friends with ThunderClan.

[StarryNebula]

Blackstar is my favorite (Lepordstar is a close second) and I didn't like Onestar

[Deerlie]

My favorite leader is a thunderclan leader. He is pretty cool because he knows how's to act and what to do. He is so calm when Sol came around. He did act a little mad but other than that he was calm. He knows he was on the right track to make his clan a better place. The cat is Fire star!

My least favorite leader is a ShadowClan leader. He trained kits when they were to young and they died in battle training along with battles. My dad thed least favorite is another ShadowClan leader. He didn't get his nine lives from starclan so he lied to his whole clan. They are Broken star and Nightstar.

[bobtail]

My favourite is a tie between Bluestar, because I love her backstory the most; and Tallstar because I also love his backstory and I really like to ship him.

My least favourite is Brokenstar because he hurt Yellowbaefang.

[Bracken12]

Worst Leader? one name......Bramblestar. I liked him when he was a warrior, but when he became deputy is when I lost all hope for him. And his kits I'm sorry for who ever likes them but I think Alderheart and Sparkpelt are amazingly....dull.

Best Leader? I have to say I really liked The following: Tallstar, Bluestar, Crookedstar, Tigerstar ( yes I'm one of those people), and Sunstar!
reasons
Crookedstar: He was actually developed
Tallstar: I love his loyalty to his friend Jake and who doesn't like to ship Jake and him?
Bluestar: I loved it when she went off the deep end
Tigerstar: he could have made a good leader if he was willing to do what was right ( we all know it was good ol' Pinestar's son who messed it up? Pinestar left the clan even though he knew his little baby would be evil!)
Sunstar: He loved Moonflower, and was more of a father to Bluestar than Stormtail ever was. It made him so angry that a tom couldn't love a she-cat as pretty, kind, and beautiful as her. I'm going to write a fanfiction about him!

[Tundra]

My Favorite leader is Bluestar. She is a well developed character and I like her back story. My second favorite is Crookedstar. He was injured when he was a kit, and his mother disclaimed him. He was looked down on by many cats. But he never gave up hope, he stood tall and served his clan well.
~~~~
My least favorite is Onestar. When he was a warrior he was such good friends with Firestar. Then when he became leader it all changed,
their friendship broke and
he broke the promise to stay friends with ThunderClan.

[Dust]

Honestly.... Leafstar (Skyclan) is my favorite leader :v I don't remember much from when I read the book except I really loved her character and not many people talk about her. Besides that, I didn't have any hated leader character wise, but moral wise I think Brokenstar was my least favorite.

[AbsurdJinx]

Crookedstar! :happycat::heart:

Bluestar :( :mad:

[Role]

Bluestar is fav

Firestar.... eh

And Rowanstar... no. I literally know nothing about Rowanstar except his mate is tawny and he became a leader after Blackstar... theres not much to offer yet. Or did i miss something/forget it

[Seraphon]

Top Ten from most favorite to least favorite:

1. Blackstar. Idk know if this was an error or not but he used to be one of Tigerstar's followers but he then developed into a proud maybe too proud ShadowClan leader that had some flaws, or at least flaws that were easy to see, actually make that lots of flaws XD unlike Firestar.

2. Tallstar. His backstory. Need I say more? XD

3. Crookedstar. His backstory. Again, need I say more? XD

4. Onestar. Onestar's personality technically never changed... Well I guess itdid.. Well you'll know what I mean if you watch this (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=JcrO3AYK-SE) video.

5. Brokenstar. His backstory was SO sad I HATE LIZARDFANG SO MUCHH!!!! EEEERRRGGGG ALMOST AS MUCH AS I HATE MILLIE!!!! XD DX

6. Sunstar. He may not have been around that long but you have to admit he was a good, good cat... R.I.P Suntar...

7. Tigerstar. He thought what he was doing was what StarClan wanted... But when he realized that it wasn't it was already too late... Plus he was really hard to get rid of and strong too.

8. Cloudstar. He was obviously a very intelligent leader and he stayed with his Clan until the very end...

9. Rowanstar. So far he seems to have a lot in common with Blackstar, Sunstar, and maybe Onestar.

10. Nightstar. He was trying to help his Clan but ended up making things worse... At least he tried LIKE NO ONE ELSE IN SHADOWCLAN AT THE TIME! So you can't really blame him. Plus, his backstory(I believe it's in Yelloefang's Secret).

Top from least favorite to most favorite:

1. Bluestar. The way she broke down and literally took care of NOTHING and left everything else to Fireheart. I just- I can't... And she should have made Swiftpaw a warrior at the right time! If she did he wouldn't have died!!!!!!!

2. Firestar. Idk... He just didn't seem to have many flaws... Just look at this (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fl52AZDGGxI) video... It's not that I don't like him as a cat like if I met him... It's just that... He's kinda boring XD

3. Bramblestar. HES LITERALLY TRYING TO BE FIRESTAR! Like, stop TRYING to live in someone else's shadow!!! YOU BECAME LEADER FOR A REASON!!!!

4. Leopardstar. *sigh* where do I even begin...? She teamed up with the CLEARLY EVIL Tigerstar(it's no excuse if she had a crush on him), She agreed to kill some of her cats and one of those cats she made deputy afterwards!!! And I don't think she even apologized!!! There's more I'm just too tired to write it all...

5. Pinestar. For very obvious reasons.

[Leucos]

Ok my favorites are Bluestar firestar maybe just maybe crookedstar
Bluestar is the original leader I came across the first time while reading fire and ice so I stick with the original and I like firestar since he's original and is loyalty and crookedstar is an idk! But I HATE Tigerstar since he is a backstabber a lier a traitor a killer and a jerk! He killed redtail !!!

It makes me so GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARH!

:3

[Static]

My favorite leader defeinently has to be crooked star because he didn't become a cold blooded murderer like most cats would when he saw everyone around him he love die and plus have mapleshade alwase telling him to do things.My least favorite has to be bramblestar.He is alwase comparing himself to firestar and he's just...I don't know how to explain it.

[wickedvirtues]

Favorites:
Crookedstar - After his sad past, he got to become a leader and serve his Clan well.
Mistystar - I found her sweet and likable, with her attitude.
Tallstar - I REALLY enjoyed his friendship with Firestar, and just what I got to read of him in general.
Blackstar - I don't know too much about him, but I think he was a good cat and he was very loyal to his Clan.

Least favorites:
Bluestar - I enjoyed her for a bit, and I felt bad for her with the whole Tigerstar thing. But why didn't she trust..I don't know. ANY OTHER LOYAL CAT IN THE CLAN?! Longtail, sure, Darkstripe, of course! But the others didn't do anything! She was the reason Brightpaw and Swiftpaw snuck out, one of them got killed, and the other disfigured.
Onestar- As Onewhisker I liked him. I thought he'd be a kind but strict leader. But nope. He just abandoned Firestar.
Brokenstar - Obvious reasons.
Tigerstar - Obvious reaons.

[Zan Partizanne]

(Quick question do you guys think HareStar will do better then OneStar?)

[Tundra]

[If your talking about Vision of Shadows im not there yet]

[Zan Partizanne]

( Oh Sorry XD )